What Makes A Contract Valid In Real Estate?

Learn essential elements to make a real estate contract valid in Utah. From mutual consent to a written agreement, ensure your transactions are legally binding.

Ruf gill
7 min readAug 2, 2024

What Makes A Contract Valid In Real Estate?

When navigating the complex world of real estate transactions in Utah, it’s crucial to understand what makes a contract valid. Whether you’re buying your first home in Salt Lake City or selling a property in Provo, you need to know the fundamentals and requirements that ensure your contracts are legally binding and enforceable. This article will guide you through the essential elements of a valid real estate contract under the Utah Code, unravel common misconceptions, and empower you with actionable insights.

What Makes A Contract Valid In Real Estate?

Understanding the Essentials of a Valid Real Estate Contract

A valid real estate contract in Utah must meet specific criteria. Without these key elements, the agreement might not hold up in court, leading to potential disputes and financial losses. So, what exactly are the fundamental principles that you need to be aware of?

Mutual Consent

The first essential element is mutual consent or agreement. Both parties involved in the contract must clearly understand and agree to the terms stated. This is often achieved through the offer and acceptance process. One party proposes an offer, and the other party must accept it unconditionally. According to Utah Code Section 25–5–4, “No agreement, promise, or undertaking relating to real estate, by which any such person’s performance or forbearance is promised, shall be binding unless written in a formal contract.”

Offer and Acceptance

Offer and acceptance are critical to mutual consent. The offer must be clear and certain. For example, if you’re buying a home in Draper, your offer should specify the price, closing date, and any contingencies. The seller must accept every term of the offer without alteration for the contract to be valid. If the seller modifies the offer (like changing the price), it becomes a counteroffer that you must then accept.

Jeremy Eveland Utah Attorney

Consideration

Another pivotal aspect is consideration. This refers to something of value that each party agrees to exchange. While it often involves money, consideration can also include services or promises. Under Utah statute, consideration is necessary for a contract to be enforceable. Consideration’s importance cannot be overstated, as it validates the contract and provides grounds for enforcement if a dispute arises.

Legal Capacity

Legal capacity means that the parties entering the contract must have the legal ability to do so. They must be of sound mind and not minors. A contract signed by someone lacking legal capacity, such as a minor or someone deemed mentally incompetent, is typically voidable. In real estate transactions, securing a proper identification and ensuring all parties have legal capacity is crucial for the contract’s validity.

Lawful Purpose

The contract must have a lawful purpose. Any agreement to engage in illegal activities, even if it meets all other criteria, will not be upheld by the courts. For example, a contract to purchase a property in West Valley City for the use of illegal gambling would be invalid.

Written Agreement

Perhaps one of the most crucial elements, especially in real estate transactions, is that the contract must be in writing. According to the Statute of Frauds, as per Utah Code 25–5–4, certain contracts, including those involving real estate, must be in writing to be enforceable. This helps prevent fraud and misunderstandings. The written contract should detail all key terms, including the property description, sale price, and obligations of each party.

Visual Aid: Critical Elements of a Valid Real Estate Contract

To simplify, here’s a visual representation of the critical elements you need to ensure a valid real estate contract:

Elements of a Valid Real Estate Contract

Diagram Explanation

  1. Mutual Consent: Both parties agree to the terms.
  2. Offer and Acceptance: Clear proposals and unconditional agreements.
  3. Consideration: Something of value exchanged.
  4. Legal Capacity: Parties must be legally capable.
  5. Lawful Purpose: The objective must be lawful.
  6. Written Agreement: Must be documented in writing.

Real-World Application: A Real Estate Scenario in Layton

Imagine this: You find your dream home in Layton, and you’re ready to make an offer. You consult with your real estate agent and prepare a written offer that includes the purchase price, closing date, and any contingencies, such as a home inspection. The seller reviews your offer and initially agrees but decides to change the closing date. They submit a counteroffer with the altered terms. If you accept the counteroffer, both parties sign the written contract, fulfilling all essential elements — mutual consent, consideration, legal capacity, lawful purpose, and written agreement.

The Role of the Utah Code in Protecting Your Rights

Utah’s legal framework provides stability and predictability in real estate transactions. According to Utah Code 57–1–1, “all deeds, contracts, or writings of, or concerning whatsoever amounts to property or any interest therein,” must be properly executed and acknowledged. This statute underscores the importance of a methodical approach to completing and signing real estate contracts.

Laws such as these protect your rights by ensuring transparency and fairness. For example, knowing that the contract must clearly outline the terms protects you from unexpected changes or hidden conditions that could jeopardize your purchase or sale.

Common Misconceptions in Real Estate Contracts

Despite clear guidelines, misconceptions about real estate contracts persist, potentially leading to costly mistakes. Let’s tackle some of these misconceptions to enhance your understanding and decision-making skills.

Misconception 1: Verbal Agreements Are Binding

Some believe that a verbal agreement is enough to make a real estate contract binding. However, as noted earlier, the Statute of Frauds in Utah requires that contracts for the sale of real estate be in writing. A verbal agreement won’t be enforceable if a dispute arises, leaving you unprotected.

Misconception 2: All Offers Are Binding

An offer doesn’t become binding until accepted. Until the other party accepts your offer, it remains open and can be withdrawn or altered. Importantly, the acceptance must match the offer exactly — any modifications create a counteroffer that requires your acceptance.

Misconception 3: Handshake Deals Are Enforceable

Another common misconception is the belief that a handshake deal can seal a real estate transaction. While a handshake may indicate mutual agreement, it doesn’t replace the need for a written contract. When disputes occur, courts need a documented record of the agreed terms.

What Makes A Contract Valid In Real Estate?

Practical Application: Avoiding Common Pitfalls

Understanding these laws is essential not just in theory but also in practice. Let’s consider a practical application to avoid common pitfalls in real estate contracts.

Scenario: Selling a Property in Ogden

Suppose you’re selling your property in Ogden and receive multiple offers. One buyer insists on a verbal agreement over the phone, promising to follow up with paperwork later. Trusting their word, you stop entertaining other offers. However, the buyer never sends the paperwork, and you lose out on other potential buyers. To avoid this, remember that only written agreements are binding in real estate transactions. Always insist on documented offers and contracts to protect your interests.

Actionable Insights for a Successful Real Estate Transaction

Gaining a comprehensive understanding of what makes a contract valid can significantly impact your real estate transactions. Here are some actionable insights to ensure your dealings are seamless and legally sound.

Tips for Buyers and Sellers

  • Seek Professional Guidance: Consult with a real estate agent and a knowledgeable attorney to navigate the complexities of real estate contracts.
  • Ensure Clarity: Make sure all terms and conditions are clearly stated in the written contract, leaving no room for ambiguity.
  • Verify Legal Capacity: Confirm that all parties involved are legally able to enter into the contract.
  • Document Everything: From initial offers to final agreements, keep a written record of all correspondence and agreements.
  • Understand Contingencies: Be aware of any contingencies in the contract and ensure they are clearly defined and agreed upon.

FAQs About Real Estate Contracts in Utah

Q1: Do real estate contracts need to be notarized in Utah?
A: While it’s not a legal requirement for real estate contracts to be notarized in Utah, having documents notarized can add an extra layer of verification and authenticity, reducing the risk of disputes.

Q2: Can a minor enter into a real estate contract in Utah?
A: No, a minor cannot enter into a legally binding real estate contract in Utah. Contracts with minors are typically voidable due to the lack of legal capacity.

Q3: What happens if a contingency in the contract is not met?
A: If a contingency is not met, the contract can become void. For example, if the sale is contingent on a satisfactory home inspection and the inspection reveals significant issues, the buyer can withdraw from the contract without penalties.

Q4: Can a real estate contract be modified after it is signed?
A: Yes, but any modifications must be agreed upon by all parties and documented in writing. These amendments ensure that changes are clear and enforceable.

Final Takeaway: Empowering Your Real Estate Journey in Utah

Understanding what makes a contract valid in real estate equips you with the knowledge to navigate transactions confidently and responsibly. By prioritizing mutual consent, clear offers and acceptances, proper consideration, legal capacity, lawful purpose, and written agreements, you ensure that your real estate contracts are enforceable and beneficial.

To dive deeper into these laws or resolve any lingering concerns, speaking with a lawyer can provide personalized guidance tailored to your specific situation. Call attorney Jeremy Eveland at (801) 613–1472 to ensure you’re on the right path.

In conclusion, comprehending the intricacies of real estate contracts empowers you to make informed decisions, protect your rights, and navigate the complexities of the real estate market with confidence. If you found this article helpful, please clap, leave a comment, and subscribe to our Medium newsletter for more updates on legal topics!

Jeremy Eveland 8833 S Redwood Rd West Jordan Utah 84088 (801) 613–1472

The information contained in this article is for information purposes only and is not legal advice. For legal advice, hire a competent lawyer in your jurisdiction.

--

--