What Are Three Things That Can Cause A Contract To Be Void?
Discover the essential elements that can make a contract void: lack of capacity, illegal purpose, and absence of mutual assent, with insights specific to Utah laws.
What Are Three Things That Can Cause A Contract To Be Void?
Contracts are the backbone of many agreements in daily life, from buying a car to leasing an apartment or starting a new job. But what happens when a contract doesn’t stand up to legal scrutiny? Understanding the key elements that make a contract void is essential for ensuring you don’t end up in a legally tenuous situation. Let’s explore three primary reasons a contract might be void, focusing on laws specific to Utah, and explain each in a way that empowers you with practical legal knowledge.
The Basics: What Makes a Contract?
Before diving into what makes a contract void, it’s essential to understand what constitutes a valid contract. Simply put, a contract is an agreement between two or more parties that creates mutual obligations enforceable by law. In Utah, for a contract to be valid, it must meet these critical elements:
- Offer and Acceptance — One party must make an offer that the other party accepts.
- Consideration — There must be something of value exchanged between the parties.
- Mutual Assent — Both parties must agree to the terms.
- Legal Purpose — The purpose of the contract must be lawful.
- Capacity — Both parties must have the legal ability to enter into a contract.
Now that you have a grasp of what makes a contract valid, let’s delve into what can make one void.
1. Lack of Capacity
What Is Legal Capacity?
Legal capacity is one of the cornerstone principles in contract law. In essence, it refers to the ability of a party to enter into a legally binding contract. According to the Utah Code, certain individuals lack the capacity to contract, including minors, mentally incapacitated persons, and intoxicated individuals.
Minors and Contracts
In Utah, a minor (anyone under 18 years old) generally does not have the capacity to enter into a contract. There are exceptions, such as contracts for necessities (food, clothing, shelter), but these are limited. For example, if a 17-year-old signs a lease agreement, that contract could be voidable at their discretion.
Citation: Utah Code § 15–2–1 states that contracts made by minors are voidable at the minor’s discretion.
Mentally Incapacitated Persons
If a person is deemed mentally incapacitated by a court, they lack the capacity to enter into a contract. This includes individuals with mental disorders or illnesses that impair their understanding of the contract terms.
Example: Imagine a resident of Salt Lake City named John, who suffers from severe schizophrenia. If John enters into a contract to buy a car, his family could argue in court that the contract is void due to his mental state.
Intoxication
While less common, intoxication can also render a contract void if the intoxicated party can prove that they were unable to understand the nature and consequences of the agreement.
Citation: Utah Code § 75–2–201 covers the requirements for proving incapacity due to intoxication.
2. Illegality of Contract’s Purpose
What Constitutes an Illegal Contract?
A contract’s purpose must be legal for it to be enforceable. Any contract that involves illegal activities under Utah law is void. This means that the courts will not assist in enforcing agreements that are against the law.
Examples of Illegal Contracts
- Contracts for Gambling — While some forms of gambling are legal in Utah, betting contracts outside these boundaries are void.
- Citation: Utah Code § 76–10–1102 makes unregulated gambling illegal.
- Drug Trade Contracts — Any agreement involving the sale or distribution of illegal substances is void.
- Example: A contract to sell marijuana, which is illegal for recreational use in Utah, would be void.
- Contracts Involving Fraud — Any agreement based on fraudulent terms or activities is inherently illegal and thus void.
Example: Suppose you enter a contract with a company in Provo that promises “guaranteed” returns on a fraudulent investment scheme. The contract is void due to its fraudulent nature.
Public Policy Concerns
Some contracts, though not explicitly illegal, may still be void if they violate public policy. These contracts can’t be enforced because they’re deemed harmful to society.
Citation: Utah Code § 78B-6–504 provides guidelines on contracts that go against public policy.
3. Absence of Mutual Assent
What Is Mutual Assent?
Mutual assent refers to the agreement between parties on the terms of the contract, often manifested through the process of offer and acceptance. If there is a significant misunderstanding, misrepresentation, or mistake about a crucial contract term, mutual assent is lacking.
Misrepresentation and Fraud
If one party enters into a contract based on false information provided by the other party, the contract can be voided. For example, if someone sells you a car but lies about its condition, you may have grounds to void the contract due to misrepresentation.
Citation: Utah Code § 13–11–4 outlines consumer protection against fraudulent representations.
Example: Sarah, a resident of Ogden, buys what she believes to be an antique table from a local shop. Later, she discovers the table is a modern replica. The shop’s misrepresentation can make the contract voidable.
Mistake
Contracts can also be voided if there is a mutual mistake — meaning both parties were mistaken about a fundamental fact of the agreement.
Example: Imagine two parties in Sandy contract for the sale of a commercial property, each believing it includes certain mineral rights. If it turns out neither party owns those rights, the contract may be void due to mutual mistake.
Duress and Undue Influence
If a contract is signed under duress or undue influence, it lacks mutual assent. Duress involves threats or pressure, while undue influence involves taking improper advantage due to a relationship.
Citation: Utah Code § 76–5–203 covers criminal duress in the context of contracts.
Example: Linda, living in West Valley City, is pressured by her landlord to sign a contract under threat of eviction. This duress could render the contract void.
Why Understanding Void Contracts Matters
Understanding what can make a contract void is crucial in navigating your daily interactions and agreements. Utah’s laws are designed to protect your rights and ensure fair dealings. By knowing these principles, you can better avoid legal pitfalls and ensure that any contract you enter is valid and enforceable.
Protecting Your Rights
Knowing the grounds for void contracts helps you safeguard your rights. Whether you’re a minor, dealing with a mental health issue, or have encountered fraudulent terms, these laws provide you with a way to nullify unfair agreements.
Resolving Disputes
Contracts that are void can’t be enforced, which means parties don’t have to fulfill obligations that aren’t legally binding. This can be particularly helpful in resolving disputes where one party tries to enforce an unfair or illegal contract.
Regulating Activities
These laws also serve to regulate activities within Utah, ensuring that illegal activities or unfair practices don’t receive legal backing. This maintains a fair playing field for all parties involved in a contractual agreement.
Common Misconceptions
All Contracts Are Final
A common misconception is that once you sign a contract, you’re irrevocably bound by it. However, understanding the principles of capacity, legality, and mutual assent can help you recognize when a contract is void and unenforceable.
Verbal Contracts Can’t Be Void
Many people believe that only written contracts can be voided. However, verbal agreements can also be void if they lack legal capacity, involve illegal activities, or lack mutual assent.
Mutual Mistakes Are Rare
Another misconception is that mutual mistakes are rare. In reality, misunderstandings about fundamental aspects of a contract happen more frequently than you might think, making those contracts voidable.
Practical Applications and Pitfalls
Preemptive Measures
To avoid entering into a void contract, always ensure you understand the terms and that the contract meets all validity requirements.
Tip: When in doubt, consult with a legal professional to review any significant contract.
Knowing When to Walk Away
Recognize the signs of a void contract can empower you to walk away from unfavorable agreements. For example, if you’re faced with undue pressure to sign a contract, knowing that it can be void due to duress helps you make a more informed decision.
Protecting Your Finances
Entering into a void contract can have financial repercussions. For instance, you might invest in a business partnership only to find that the contract is void due to an illegal purpose, causing potential losses. Awareness can help you steer clear of these financial pitfalls.
Conclusion: Empower Yourself with Knowledge
Understanding what makes a contract void helps you navigate agreements with confidence and responsibility. From lacking legal capacity, involving illegal purpose, to absence of mutual assent, each element plays a critical role in the validity of a contract. By acquainting yourself with these principles, you are better equipped to protect your rights, resolve disputes, and regulate activities in a fair manner.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can a contract be partially void?
Yes, parts of a contract can be void if they deal with illegal activities or are unenforceable, while the rest of the contract remains valid.
2. Are online contracts subject to the same rules?
Absolutely. Online contracts must meet the same validity criteria (capacity, legality, mutual assent) as traditional contracts in Utah.
3. How can I prove a contract is void?
You would need evidence such as proof of incapacity, documentation of illegal activities, or evidence of misrepresentation, mistake, duress, or undue influence.
4. Can you void a contract after it has been fulfilled?
Voiding a contract after fulfillment is complex and typically requires undeniable proof that it was void from the outset, due to reasons like fraud or lack of capacity.
For those navigating legal challenges, remember: To speak with a lawyer, call attorney Jeremy Eveland at (801) 613–1472.
Engage with Us
If you found this article helpful, please clap for this article, leave a comment, and subscribe to our Medium newsletter for more updates. Your feedback helps us create more impactful content that empowers you with essential legal knowledge. Jeremy Eveland 8833 S Redwood Rd West Jordan Utah 84088 (801) 613–1472
The information contained in this article is for information purposes only and is not legal advice. For legal advice, hire a competent lawyer in your jurisdiction.
